Wondering whether the author of a website really had the PhD and teaching experience they claimed, a Hacker News commenter asked ChatGPT to look for evidence from the institutions named. In about 30 seconds it pointed them to university pages backing up the claims, including a list of past PhD recipients and a university page linking to the author's personal site.
The author of [WEBSITE, ARTICLE OR PROFILE LINK] says they have [CLAIMED QUALIFICATION OR ROLE] from [INSTITUTION OR ORGANISATION]. Please look for evidence from independent, official sources, such as the institution's own website, a public register or a professional body, that supports or contradicts this. List each source with a link and one line on what it shows. Tell me if you couldn't find anything, and don't treat the person's own website as proof on its own.
Replace the [PLACEHOLDERS] with your own details before you send it.
How to try it
- Note exactly what the person claims, including the qualification, the institution and any dates.
- Ask ChatGPT to search for evidence from official sources, using the prompt above.
- Open every link it gives you and read the relevant page yourself.
- Look for two-way links: the institution pointing to the person, not just the person pointing to the institution.
- If you still can’t confirm it, contact the institution or professional register directly.
Why this works
Anyone can write ‘PhD’ or ‘qualified expert’ on a website, and it’s sensible to check before you trust their advice, hire them or share their work. Checking used to mean trawling through university pages and registers by hand. A search-enabled chat can do that legwork quickly and hand you the links, and as the commenter found, it can be done in under a minute. The key is that you still open the sources and judge them yourself. Our guide to spotting fake images and news with AI covers more ways to check what you read online.
Tips to get a better result
- Ask for official registers in your country for regulated jobs, such as builders, accountants or therapists.
- Check the dates match: a degree awarded after someone says they started teaching is worth a closer look.
- If someone is pushing you to pay quickly, our guide to spotting scams with AI can help.
- Save the links you find, in case you need to refer back to them.
Common mistakes
- Trusting the AI’s summary without opening the sources; it can mix up people with similar names.
- Treating a lack of results as proof of a lie; some records simply aren’t online.
- Sharing accusations publicly before you’ve confirmed the facts.
Try a variation
Here’s a variation of our own to try next:
I'm about to hire [TRADE OR PROFESSIONAL] called [NAME OR COMPANY] in [AREA]. Tell me which official registers or accreditation schemes I should check for this kind of work, with links, and what to look for on each.
Related
- AI for learning: our hub of ideas
- Spot fake images and news with AI
- Spot scam emails and texts with AI
More learning use cases
Turn your ‘read later’ pile into a short audio summary with NotebookLM
An XDA writer fed NotebookLM the links from about 30 old 'read later' bookmarks and generated an Audio Overview. The 15-minute discussion pulled out the key ideas and showed which three articles were worth reading properly.
These sources are articles I saved to read later about [TOPICS]. Group them by theme, give me the three or four big ideas they share, and tell me which [NUMBER] articles are most worth reading in full and why. Point out any that mostly repeat the others.
Get a long, readable history primer on a period you love with Perplexity
A history fan asked Perplexity to write them a 10,000-word essay on American history from 1600 to 1776, then read it all the way through. They said they came away feeling smarter and better informed.
I enjoy history and want a long read on [PERIOD AND PLACE, E.G. TUDOR ENGLAND 1485-1603]. Write it as a readable essay of about [LENGTH] words, in chapters with headings, for someone who [KNOWS A LITTLE / IS NEW TO THIS]. Cover the main events, the people involved, everyday life and why it still matters. Cite your sources as you go, point out where historians disagree, and finish with five well-regarded books I could read next.
Make verb charts to help your child learn a language with Claude
A parent who doesn't speak Romanian used Claude to make verb charts and pages for their son, explaining each tense in English first. The polished first drafts didn't sink in, so they went through sentence by sentence, making Claude rewrite anything unclear until the ideas were easy to follow.
My child is learning [LANGUAGE] and is struggling with [VERB OR TENSE]. I don't speak the language. Make a one-page chart that first explains how this tense works in plain English, then shows the [LANGUAGE] forms with a short example sentence and English translation for each. Use short sentences a [AGE]-year-old can follow. If anything you write is vague, say so.
Reference: Hacker News (ndriscoll)