Black Friday on 27 November kicks off the busiest few weeks of online shopping of the year, and it’s also when fake shops do their best business. A website with a famous brand’s logo, a price that’s half what everyone else charges and a countdown timer can look convincing at 11pm on a phone screen.
AI can be the calm second opinion you need before you pay. Paste in the web address, the offer and what the site says about returns, and a chatbot can point out the warning signs, tell you what to check and help you decide whether to walk away. It can’t promise a shop is genuine, but it’s very good at slowing you down. This guide takes about 5 minutes per shop.
Quick answer: Before buying from a shop you don’t know, paste the web address, the price and the returns information into an AI chatbot and ask it to list the warning signs and what to check. Then check independent reviews yourself, type the brand’s official address into your browser rather than clicking links, pay by credit card or a payment service with buyer protection and never by bank transfer.
New to AI? Start with our beginner’s guide.
What you’ll need
- The web address of the shop, or the link you were sent
- A screenshot or copy of the offer, the price and the returns or delivery page
- An AI chatbot such as ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini or Grok
- A credit card or a payment service such as PayPal, Apple Pay or Google Pay, if you have one
- About 5 minutes per shop
Step-by-step: check an online shop with AI
- Don’t click straight through. If a text, email or social media advert sends you to a deal, the NCSC suggests typing the official website address into your browser yourself, or searching for the shop and reading the results rather than clicking the top one.
- Ask the AI for a first check. Paste the web address and the offer and ask for a list of warning signs and things to verify, such as a misspelt domain, missing contact details or prices that are far below other shops (prompt 1). Never paste card numbers or passwords.
- Check the web address carefully. The NCSC warns that criminals copy the design of real shops and use deceptive addresses, such as www.tescos-sales.com instead of www.tesco.com. Ask the AI to compare the address with the brand’s real one.
- Look for independent reviews. Search for the shop’s name plus “reviews” or “scam” on consumer websites and from people you trust. Ask the AI to help you judge whether the reviews look genuine (prompt 2).
- Pay the safer way. The NCSC says to use a credit card if you have one, as many purchases are protected under the Consumer Credit Act, and never to pay by direct bank transfer. Debit cards offer less protection, but you may be able to claim a refund through chargeback.
- Give as little as possible at checkout. Check out as a guest where you can, only fill in the required fields and don’t let the shop or your browser save your card details.
- Know what to do if it goes wrong. Use prompt 3 to get a calm action list: contact your bank, report the site and keep evidence. If you’ve paid a scammer, the NCSC says to tell your bank and report it to Report Fraud (England, Wales and Northern Ireland) or Police Scotland.
Copy-paste prompts
1. Is this shop genuine?
I'm thinking of buying [ITEM] for [PRICE] from this website: [WEB ADDRESS]. I found it through [AN ADVERT / A TEXT / AN EMAIL / A SEARCH]. Here is what the site says about delivery, returns and contact details: [PASTE TEXT]. Act as a careful, slightly sceptical friend. List any warning signs you can see, the five things I should check myself before paying, and whether the price looks realistic compared with what this item normally costs. Don't tell me the shop is safe: tell me what to verify.
2. Do these reviews look real?
Here are some reviews I found for an online shop: [PASTE 5 TO 10 REVIEWS, WITH DATES IF SHOWN]. Tell me whether they look genuine or suspicious and explain why, for example lots of short five-star reviews posted on the same day, vague wording or reviews that don't mention the product. Then tell me where else I could look for independent reviews.
3. I think I’ve been scammed
I bought [ITEM] from [SHOP NAME] on [DATE] for [AMOUNT], paid by [CREDIT CARD / DEBIT CARD / PAYPAL / BANK TRANSFER]. Now [THE PARCEL HASN'T ARRIVED / THE SITE HAS DISAPPEARED / I GOT A FAKE ITEM]. Give me a calm step-by-step action list for the UK, in order of urgency: who to contact first, what to say to my bank, how to report it and what evidence to keep. Remind me to use official contact details, not ones from the shop's emails.
4. Gift shopping safety checklist
I'm doing my Christmas shopping online this year from these shops: [LIST]. Make me a one-page safety checklist I can keep next to me while I shop, covering checking the shop, paying, passwords, delivery texts and what to do if something goes wrong. Keep it short and in plain English.
Recommended tools
- ChatGPT: quick, clear checks of a web address and an offer, plus easy checklists
- Claude: careful at spotting vague or suspicious wording in returns pages and reviews
- Gemini: handy for comparing a price with what the item usually costs elsewhere
- Grok: fast answers when you’re about to pay and want a second opinion
Got a “deal” by text or email? Paste it into a chatbot using our guide to spotting scam emails and texts with AI. Fake shops often use stolen or AI-made product photos, so learn how to spot AI-generated images and fake news, and if a genuine order arrives faulty or not at all, see how to write a complaint letter that gets results with AI.
Tips and mistakes to avoid
- Too good to be true usually is. A big-name product at half price from a shop you’ve never heard of is a classic warning sign, especially around Black Friday.
- AI can’t see the whole picture. A chatbot can miss a brand-new fake site or be fooled by a convincing one. Use it to slow down and check, not as a guarantee.
- Never paste card details or passwords into a chatbot. Describe the problem instead.
- Use unique passwords and 2-step verification. The NCSC recommends strong, unique passwords for shopping, banking and email accounts, plus 2-step verification, so one leaked password doesn’t unlock everything.
- Report suspicious messages. Forward scam emails to report@phishing.gov.uk and scam texts to 7726, and report a suspicious website to the NCSC.
- Check payment app cover. If you pay with PayPal, Apple Pay or Google Pay, check their terms to see what protection you get.
FAQ
Can AI tell me if a website is a scam?
Not for certain. It can spot common warning signs and tell you what to check, but it can’t verify who runs a site. Check independent reviews and the official brand website yourself before paying.
What’s the safest way to pay online?
The NCSC recommends using a credit card where you can, because many purchases are protected under the Consumer Credit Act. Debit cards offer less protection, and you should never pay a shop by direct bank transfer.
What should I do if I’ve paid a fake shop?
Contact your bank straight away using its official number or app, then report it to Report Fraud (England, Wales and Northern Ireland) or Police Scotland. Keep screenshots of the website, emails and payment.
Try it yourself with ChatGPT
I'm thinking of buying [ITEM] for [PRICE] from this website: [WEB ADDRESS]. I found it through [AN ADVERT / A TEXT / AN EMAIL / A SEARCH]. Here is what the site says about delivery, returns and contact details: [PASTE TEXT]. Act as a careful, slightly sceptical friend. List any warning signs you can see, the five things I should check myself before paying, and whether the price looks realistic compared with what this item normally costs. Don't tell me the shop is safe: tell me what to verify.
Try the next prompt: once you know the shop is genuine, make sure the parcel arrives in time with our guide to planning around Christmas posting deadlines with AI
Read next
Get the free AI Agents Playbook
50 practical AI workflows, plus one practical how-to a week in your inbox.
Free. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
Reference: NCSC: Shopping and paying safely online